Tipperary TD Mattie McGrath has strongly criticized the government’s decision to conduct a non-statutory evaluation of the country’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic. He argues that this approach is inadequate for ensuring accountability, transparency, and preparedness for future public health crises. McGrath emphasizes that the proposed evaluation lacks the statutory powers needed to compel witnesses and obtain crucial documents.
Speaking from Clonmel, Deputy Mc Grath stated: “This evaluation is toothless and lacks the power to uncover the truth. Without the ability to mandate participation and gather all relevant evidence, this process risks becoming a superficial exercise rather than a meaningful investigation.”
He draws attention to how other nations have approached their inquiries into pandemic responses. The UK, for example, has launched a statutory public inquiry with full powers to investigate all aspects of its handling of COVID-19. Similarly, countries like Sweden, France, and Italy have undertaken rigorous examinations, some even initiating criminal proceedings to ensure comprehensive accountability.
TheLiberal.ie won’t quit
Please support us with a small donation on PayPal!
McGrath continues. “The government has taken too long to address this critical issue. While other countries have moved forward with robust inquiries, we are left with an evaluation that lacks depth and authority. The Irish people deserve better.”
McGrath also highlights the importance of examining specific areas such as excess deaths during the pandemic and the impact of restrictions on health services and society at large. “We need to learn from our mistakes to better protect the Irish people,” he asserts. “A full inquiry should not only identify what went wrong but also provide clear recommendations for future resilience.”
He calls for a transparent process that involves public input and addresses the concerns of those who suffered significant hardship during the pandemic. “The proposed ‘no blame’ approach turns this evaluation into a mere formality,” McGrath warns. “True accountability requires us to confront uncomfortable truths and ensure that lessons are genuinely learned.”
In conclusion, Deputy McGrath urges the government to reconsider its approach and commit to a statutory inquiry that can deliver justice and clarity for all affected by the pandemic. “This is not just about looking back,” he says. “It’s about ensuring we are prepared for whatever challenges may come in the future.”
Tell us your thoughts in the Facebook post and share this with your friends.
